Private schools must exercise zero-risk judgment; JKBOSE must enforce accountability and safety norms. The Board cannot remain a silent spectator after repeated incidents that expose gaps in school safety governance. There is an urgent need for clear, enforceable guidelines on school excursions, mandatory weather-based advisories, prior permissions, and strict penalties for violations
· Serious questions raised over school picnic clearance in foggy conditions, private schools’ decision-making under scrutiny after fog-related accident, why was a picnic allowed when visibility was compromised? adverse weather ignored, children put at risk, safety lapses exposed in school excursion planning
ALSO READ THIS:IndiGo’s crew crisis hits J&K and key Metros hard
The recent road accident involving a private school picnic bus on the Bishnah Ring Road in Jammu has triggered deep public concern over the safety standards, preparedness, and decision-making protocols followed by private educational institutions, particularly during off-campus student excursions.On Saturday evening, a bus carrying 40 students and 10 members of the teaching staff from a private school in the Pragwal border area met with an accident while returning from a day-long picnic in Samba.
According to reports, the bus hit a road divider and overturned, allegedly after the driver lost control of the vehicle. Crucially, the incident occurred under foggy weather conditions, which severely reduced visibility and posed clear risks to road safety.As a result of the mishap, around 25 students and six teachers sustained injuries. The injured include Saveeta Manhas, Bandna Kumari, Saroj Devi, Naksh Thakur, Neeraj Singh, Mavisksha Rajput, Paras Rajput, Abhay Kumar, Dhanvir Singh, Sneha Manhas, Jeewan Manhas, Manvi Sharma, Lakshmi Verma, and Sohan Singh.
While most of the injured are being treated at Bishnah Hospital, six critically injured persons were referred to Government Medical College (GMC) Jammu for advanced medical care.The prompt and coordinated response of the local police, along with the dedicated and professional efforts of the medical teams at Bishnah Hospital and GMC Jammu, is highly commendable. Their swift action undoubtedly helped prevent a far more tragic outcome. Despite the effective emergency response, the incident exposes serious lapses in precautionary decision-making. A fundamental question that demands a clear and transparent answer is:
Why was a school picnic permitted and undertaken despite adverse weather conditions, particularly dense fog that significantly compromised visibility and safety? When children leave school premises under institutional supervision, the responsibility of their safety rests entirely with the school management. Parents entrust schools with their children in good faith, expecting that every possible risk will be assessed and mitigated.
Any school activity conducted outside the campus especially picnics and excursions must strictly adhere to the highest safety standards, including thorough assessment of weather forecasts and road conditions, mandatory fitness and safety checks of transport vehicles, engagement of experienced, well-rested, and trained drivers, clearly defined emergency response and medical preparedness plans, real-time monitoring of school transport during travel.
This unfortunate incident should serve as a wake-up call for private schools and regulatory authorities alike. There is an urgent need to frame and enforce stricter guidelines, accountability mechanisms, and oversight systems to ensure that student safety is never compromised due to haste, poor judgment, or administrative negligence. Student safety must always take precedence over schedules, formalities, or institutional convenience. No picnic, outing, or event—howsoever well-intentioned is worth endangering young lives. Preventable risks must never be allowed to turn into life-altering tragedies.
Private schools must strictly avoid organizing picnics and outdoor excursions during foggy or adverse weather conditions because such conditions drastically reduce visibility, impair driver reaction time, and increase the likelihood of road accidents, especially on highways and ring roads with heavy traffic. Children are not ordinary passengers; they are minors whose safety demands extraordinary caution, foresight, and zero-risk tolerance.
Taking students out during fog reflects poor judgment and disregard for basic safety norms, as no recreational activity can justify exposing young lives to predictable and avoidable danger. Schools are duty-bound to postpone or cancel such plans the moment weather conditions turn unfavorable, regardless of logistical inconvenience or financial considerations.
At the same time, the Jammu and Kashmir State Board of School Education (JKBOSE) must wake up from its regulatory slumber and assume a more proactive and accountable role. The Board cannot remain a silent spectator after repeated incidents that expose gaps in school safety governance.
There is an urgent need for clear, enforceable guidelines on school excursions, mandatory weather-based advisories, prior permissions, and strict penalties for violations. Child safety must be institutionalized, not left to the discretion of individual school managements. Regulatory inaction only emboldens negligence and when children’s lives are at stake, complacency is simply unacceptable.
